Shoe trees are one of the most important tools for maintaining leather shoes. Yet many people wonder whether cedar shoe trees or plastic shoe trees are the better option.
While both types are designed to help maintain the shape of your footwear, they perform very differently when it comes to moisture control, odor prevention, and long-term shoe care.
Understanding the differences can help you protect your shoes and extend their lifespan.
What Is a Shoe Tree?
A shoe tree is a device inserted into a shoe when it is not being worn. Its main purpose is to help maintain the shoe's shape and prevent creasing in the leather.
Shoe trees are commonly used for:
-
Leather dress shoes
-
Boots
-
Loafers
-
Luxury sneakers
Using shoe trees regularly helps reduce wrinkles, preserve the structure of the shoe, and improve overall longevity.
What Are Cedar Shoe Trees?
Cedar shoe trees are made from natural cedar wood and are widely considered the gold standard for shoe care.
Cedar is commonly used because it has natural properties that benefit leather footwear.
Benefits of Cedar Shoe Trees
1. Moisture Absorption
When you wear shoes, moisture builds up inside from sweat and humidity. Cedar wood naturally absorbs this moisture, helping shoes dry properly.
Excess moisture can cause leather to deteriorate faster and may also create odor.
2. Odor Control
Cedar has natural antimicrobial properties that help neutralize unpleasant odors inside shoes.
3. Shape Retention
Cedar shoe trees expand gently inside the shoe, helping maintain the original shape and reduce creasing.
4. Long Lifespan
High-quality cedar shoe trees can last for many years with proper use.
What Are Plastic Shoe Trees?
Plastic shoe trees are typically made from lightweight molded plastic and are often used for inexpensive footwear or travel purposes.
They are commonly found in:
-
sneakers
-
casual shoes
-
lower-cost shoe care kits
Plastic shoe trees can help maintain the shape of shoes temporarily, but they lack many of the benefits of cedar.
Limitations of Plastic Shoe Trees
No Moisture Absorption
Plastic does not absorb moisture. This means sweat and humidity remain trapped inside the shoe.
No Odor Control
Plastic does not neutralize odors the way cedar wood naturally can.
Weaker Structure
Many plastic shoe trees are lightweight and do not apply enough pressure to properly support leather shoes.
Cedar vs Plastic Shoe Trees: Key Differences
Moisture Control
Cedar shoe trees absorb moisture and help shoes dry properly. Plastic shoe trees do not.
Odor Prevention
Cedar naturally neutralizes odors, while plastic offers no odor control.
Durability
Cedar shoe trees are durable and can last for years. Plastic shoe trees are more likely to break or lose shape.
Protection for Leather
Cedar is gentler on leather and helps maintain the shoe's natural structure.
Overall Shoe Care
Cedar shoe trees provide complete shoe care benefits, while plastic versions mainly provide temporary shape support.
Why Leather Shoes Need Shoe Trees
Leather is a natural material that flexes with movement. When shoes are worn, the leather bends and forms creases.
Without proper support, these creases can become deeper over time.
Using shoe trees after each wear helps:
-
reduce wrinkles and creasing
-
maintain the original shape of the shoe
-
allow leather to dry properly
-
extend the life of footwear
For anyone who owns quality leather shoes, shoe trees are considered essential.
When Plastic Shoe Trees Might Be Useful
Although cedar shoe trees are generally superior, plastic versions may still be useful in certain situations.
Examples include:
-
travel or packing shoes in luggage
-
temporary storage
-
inexpensive casual shoes
However, for long-term leather shoe care, cedar remains the preferred option.
How to Use Shoe Trees Properly
Using shoe trees correctly is simple and can greatly improve the longevity of your shoes.
-
Remove your shoes after wearing them.
-
Insert the shoe tree while the leather is still warm and flexible.
-
Allow the shoes to rest with the shoe trees inside overnight.
-
Store shoes in a cool, dry environment.
This routine helps restore the shape of the shoe and prevents creases from setting into the leather.
Final Thoughts
When comparing cedar shoe trees and plastic shoe trees, cedar clearly provides more benefits for maintaining leather footwear.
Cedar shoe trees help absorb moisture, control odors, maintain shape, and extend the lifespan of shoes. While plastic shoe trees can help maintain shape temporarily, they lack the natural advantages that cedar wood provides.
For anyone who values their leather shoes and wants them to last for years, investing in quality cedar shoe trees is one of the most effective steps in a proper shoe care routine.
